Should Children Own Smartphones? A Neurologist’s Perspective on Brain Development Before Age 12

By Dr. Ibrahim Allam, Consultant Neurologist, Saudi German Hospital Dubai

The question of whether children should own smartphones at a young age has become one of the most debated parenting and public health topics today. From a neurological standpoint, the issue goes far beyond discipline or lifestyle—it is directly linked to how a child’s brain develops, adapts, and matures.

According to Dr. Ibrahim Allam, Consultant Neurologist at Saudi German Hospital Dubai, early and prolonged exposure to smartphones can have measurable effects on brain development, particularly before the age of 12.

What Happens in a Child’s Brain With Continuous Screen Exposure Before Age 12?

Before the age of 12, a child’s brain undergoes an exceptionally rapid phase of development, especially in the frontal lobe—the area responsible for attention control, emotional regulation, impulse control, and decision-making.

Continuous exposure to screens places the brain in a state of overstimulation. Fast-paced videos, instant notifications, and constant content switching repeatedly activate dopamine pathways, the brain’s reward system. Over time, the brain becomes conditioned to expect immediate gratification.

This pattern can reduce a child’s ability to sustain attention, increase distractibility, and elevate the risk of anxiety and depressive symptoms. Essentially, natural reward circuits become depleted, making everyday activities such as reading, studying, or social interaction feel less engaging.

Is the Age of 12 a Critical Turning Point in Brain Development?

Yes. Neurologically, the age of 12 represents a crucial transition.

Before this age, the brain regions responsible for impulse control and emotional self-regulation are still immature. This makes children particularly vulnerable to the intense digital stimuli generated by smartphones, including constant alerts and rapidly changing content.

After the age of 12, executive control networks begin to mature gradually. This gives adolescents a relatively better ability to regulate device use and resist impulsive behavior—although risks do not disappear entirely.

Impact of Smartphones on Attention, Memory, Executive Function, and Emotional Regulation

Smartphone use affects several key brain structures:

Prefrontal Cortex: Chronic stimulation can overload this area, weakening executive function, focus, and self-control.
Hippocampus (Memory Center): Rapid switching between apps and content reduces deep learning and impairs memory consolidation.
Amygdala (Emotional Regulation): Exposure to emotionally charged or negative content can increase stress, anxiety, and emotional reactivity.

Early and excessive use may lead to long-term changes in neural connectivity. These changes can later present as attention deficits, behavioral challenges, heightened stress sensitivity, or emotional instability.

The Neurological Risk of Chronic Sleep Disruption

One of the most serious consequences of smartphone use in children is chronic sleep disturbance.

Deep sleep is essential for memory processing and for clearing neurotoxic waste products from the brain. Blue light emitted from screens suppresses melatonin secretion and disrupts the body’s internal clock, leading to:

Reduced learning and concentration capacity
Mood changes resembling depression
Decline in academic performance
Impairment of short- and long-term memory

A child who consistently sleeps poorly will struggle with cognitive performance and emotional regulation the following day. Over time, these effects may become persistent.

Should There Be a Law Preventing Smartphone Ownership Before Age 12?

From a scientific and neurological perspective, Dr. Allam supports legislation that limits smartphone ownership before the age of 12.

This position is not merely social—it is grounded in well-established data showing that:

The brain before age 12 is highly malleable and more susceptible to digital overstimulation
Early smartphone use is associated with higher rates of anxiety and depression
Poor sleep quality poses a significant risk to healthy neurological development
Smartphones are intentionally designed to promote behavioral dependency through reward-based mechanisms

Legislation can support parents by establishing a broader social framework that protects children during a developmental stage when they are not yet capable of self-regulation. In clinical practice, neurologists increasingly observe the neurological and emotional consequences of early smartphone exposure, ranging from attention disorders to emotional dysregulation and academic decline.

Smartphone use is not inherently harmful, but timing matters. Protecting the developing brain during its most vulnerable years is a responsibility shared by families, educators, healthcare professionals, and policymakers alike.

manager